AI Answer Quality Checklist
Check an AI answer claim by claim against sources you open yourself. Unverified claims are listed first; progress shows review, not truth. Browser-only.
Project and review scope
A record of how one AI answer was checked: which claims were verified against which sources, what is still unverified, and what was omitted. It records your review; it does not fact-check anything automatically, call an AI service or score the answer's truth.
Claim and source register
Record each claim you will use, the source the answer gave (or one you found), and what happened when you checked it. A claim stays Unverified until you record your own check — even when the citation looks real. Nothing here is checked automatically.
Nothing recorded yet.
- Note: No claims recorded yet. Add the specific claims you will rely on and the source you checked for each.
Review status: Not reviewed
Review progress 0 of 16 applicable rows verified (0%)
Outstanding critical findings
- Any sources or citations given are real and resolve — Not started
- Claims I'll rely on are backed by a source I checked — Not started
- Source exists and supports the claim — Not started
Review rows
5 row(s) do not apply to the project settings above; they are hidden but kept in the record.
Claim accuracy
0/3 verifiedKey claims match what I already know or can verify
Numbers, dates and names are checked, not assumed
Important claim paired with evidence
Source existence and relevance
0/4 verifiedAny sources or citations given are real and resolve
Open each source yourself. A URL or reference that looks real is still Unverified until you have checked it.
Critical
Quotes are accurate, not paraphrased as exact
Claims I'll rely on are backed by a source I checked
Critical
Source exists and supports the claim
Critical
Date and currency
0/1 verifiedDate-sensitive claim checked for currency
Omissions and completeness
0/3 verifiedIt answers the whole question, not just part
Important caveats, limits or exceptions are stated
Nothing critical is missing for my use case
Mathematical checks
0/1 verifiedMathematical steps independently checked
Uncertainty and assumptions
0/3 verifiedNo confident-sounding statements that are actually guesses
Assumptions it made are reasonable for my situation
Unverified claims and inference recorded
Bias and framing
0/1 verifiedI've considered bias or a one-sided framing
Add your own row
Keep, share and print
Nothing leaves your browser. Saving on this device is optional and only happens when you press it.
How to use this calculator
- Fill in the use case, the risk category and what you are reviewing. Choosing Moderate or High adds rows for source dates, contrary sources and high-stakes checks.
- In the claim register, add each claim you will rely on, the source the answer gave, and what happened when you opened that source yourself.
- Work through the rows — claim accuracy, sources, currency, omissions, maths, uncertainty and framing — setting each to Verified, Action required or N/A with a reason, then export, print or save the record.
How it works
Each row has one of four statuses. Review progress = verified rows ÷ applicable rows. An N/A with a reason leaves the denominator; an N/A without one still counts as unresolved. An empty or untouched list shows Not reviewed, never 100 %.
A claim only becomes Verified when you record that you checked its source and it supports the claim. A citation or URL that looks real stays Unverified until then, and a claim you will rely on that is not verified blocks “Ready for reviewer”.
Unresolved claims are listed highest priority first. There is no quality score or probability that the answer is true, no AI call and no automated fact-check: the record shows what you checked and what is still open.
Worked example
Three claims from one answer. Claim 1 (I will rely on it) cites “Smith et al. 2021, doi:10.0000/…” — not opened yet, so it is Unverified. Claim 2 was checked and the source supports it. Claim 3 is background with a source not yet checked. The register reads “1 of 3 recorded claims verified”, lists claim 1 first in the unresolved table, and the record shows Action required until claim 1's source is opened and confirmed.
Frequently asked questions
What has actually been checked?
Only what a person marked Verified, with the evidence they recorded — for claims, the source check you recorded. Everything else stays Not started, Action required or Unknown — the checklist never marks a row as checked on its own.
Can I use my own project requirements?
Yes. Describe your use case and risk category, and record your own sources and acceptance rules in the evidence fields. Add your own rows (they get stable IDs), and mark rows that do not apply as N/A with a reason — an N/A without a reason still counts as unresolved.
Does a complete checklist prove the work complies?
No. “Ready for reviewer” is your declaration that the applicable rows are verified and nothing critical is open. It does not prove an AI answer is true or that relying on it is safe; high-stakes decisions need an authoritative source or a qualified professional.
Does this use AI or send my prompt anywhere?
No. It runs entirely in your browser using rule-based checks — your prompt is never uploaded or sent to any AI model. Still, avoid pasting passwords, API keys or private data into any tool.
Related tools
- AI Hallucination Risk Checker
- AI Citation Requirements Prompt Builder
- AI Workflow Risk Checker
- Prompt Score Calculator
- AI Privacy Redaction Helper
- AI Data Analysis Prompt Builder
Explore more in AI Tools.
Cite this tool
Zerdly. (2026). AI Answer Quality Checklist. Retrieved from https://www.zerdly.com/tools/ai-answer-quality-checklist/
Tip: Enter any known values to calculate the remaining results.
Designed to run locally in your browser. Tool inputs are not intentionally stored by Zerdly unless stated otherwise.



